Unsolved murder of teenage mother exposes Brighton's sleazy secrets
Campaigners for justice accuse police of incompetence in a case of drugs, theft, revenge and murder in a graveyard. Tony Thompson reports
With its large gay community, celebrity residents and beachfront cafés, Brighton is regarded as one of the hippest, most laid-back towns in Britain. But a glimpse of its seamy underbelly emerged last week as campaigners offered a £50,000 reward to find the killers of a 19-year-old girl sucked into a world of drugs and depravity.
The case of Katrina Taylor has focused attention on the increasing problems of Brighton and on its crumbling estates a short distance from the homes of such famous residents as Zoë Ball, Chris Eubank and Heather Mills, Paul McCartney's new girlfriend. Against a backdrop of a dramatic increase in burglaries, muggings and shootings, private investigators trying to find Taylor's killers last week revealed that they had received death threats as fly-posters were put up around town calling for justice for a woman whose life was ruined by drugs.
Katrina Taylor was found stabbed to death in a graveyard in July 1996. Despite a big police inquiry and two Crown Court trials, no one has been found guilty of her murder. Campaigners believe this is because of the local force's failure to investigate the crime properly. They want a full investigation by the Police Complaints Authority.
Last week they began distributing a list of Sussex officers who are accused of varying degrees of incompetence, from allegedly failing to investigate the background of key witnesses to failing to respond to information about the whereabouts of the accused.
Thecampaigners have uncovered evidence that they say links the murder to a fraud gang operating out of nearby Peacehaven and claim this has not been properly investigated.
The murder attracted great publicity when it was discovered that the victim had taken part in a police murder reconstruction in 1986, posing as nine-year-old Nicola Fellows who had been found strangled in a Brighton park along with a friend. Ten years later, Katrina was struggling to bring up her baby daughter and fund her £200-per-week heroin habit.
Late in the evening of 8 May 1996 she agreed to act as lookout while her boyfriend Mattie Laurie and friend John Cosham burgled a house belonging to Neisha Williams, the former girlfriend of a drug dealer. As well as stealing personal belongings, the thieves set fire to furniture and flooded two rooms. After using her contacts to find out who had been responsible, Williams formed a posse which rampaged through Brighton hellbent on revenge.
Among the members of the gang were her ex-boyfriend Trevor Smith, a white Londoner obsessed with black culture who had a string of previous convictions. He called his flatmate, Fergal Scollan, who had previous convictions for assault and actual bodily harm. With Smith he had begun a large-scale operation growing super-strong 'skunk' cannabis. Williams's brother, Simon, was also in the posse.
Laurie could not be found - he had already been arrested for the robbery - so the posse tracked down Cosham. He was beaten and stabbed in both legs with a screwdriver. A friend who was found with him was stabbed in the face, beaten with a hammer and repeatedly kicked in the head. The posse then moved on to track down Katrina Taylor. They forced their way into her family home and attacked her sister, but Katrina was nowhere to be found.
The following day Katrina was arrested for her part in the burglary. Detectives asked magistrates to remand her in custody, but she was granted bail to look after her eight-month-old daughter. Nearly two months later Simon Williams spotted her outside a hotel. He persuaded her to go with him to 77 Centurion Road, the council house to which Neisha Williams had moved. Williams called Smith and Scollan who rushed back to Brighton from London. The evening began with a shouting match; at one point a knife was held to Katrina's throat and she agreed to pay for the damage caused by the burglary at the rate of £10 per week from her unemployment benefits. At 11.15pm screaming was heard in a graveyard a short walk from Centurion Road. Katrina's body was found the next morning by a man walking his dog. According to the pathologist's report, she had been held from behind and stabbed from the front by either one or two people.
Within weeks, a team of 50 detectives and 15 forensic experts had gathered 400 exhibits -including the murder weapon, which Simon Williams had disposed of down a drain in Peacehaven - and 150 statements. Neisha and Simon Williams, along with Smith and Scollan, were arrested and charged with murder.
At the trial at Lewes Crown Court in June 1997 Neisha and Simon Williams claimed Katrina had left the flat that evening with Scollan and Smith, who later returned saying she was dead. Scollan and Smith claimed she had left with the Williamses and that the exact opposite was true. Both men said they believed Simon Williams had killed Katrina and they had gone into hiding. Simon Williams admitted trying to dispose of the murder weapon.
Neisha was found guilty of false imprisonment but she and her brother were cleared of murder. Smith and Scollan were found guilty. Smith and Scollan launched an immediate appeal claiming the judge had misdirected the jury over aspects of the evidence. The Court of Appeal ordered a retrial which began at the Old Bailey in October 1999.
For legal reasons, Neisha and Simon Williams did not give evidence. Lawyers for Smith and Scollan successfully argued that there was no case to answer, and the judge directed that both men be acquitted of murder because of insufficient evidence. Scollan had a charge of false imprisonment dropped. Smith admitted the same charge and was sentenced to 30 months but walked free because of time served.
Katrina's mother, Kathy, told The Observer : 'I am disgusted how this has turned out. It has destroyed my faith in the justice system and the police. My daughter was stabbed to death and no one has been made to pay. I won't rest until they are.'
Kathy will meet campaigners this week to discuss options for moving forward. A spokesperson for Sussex Police said: 'The police thoroughly investigated this murder. The file remains open, and if anyone has information we would urge them to come forward.'
© Copyright Guardian Media Group plc. 2000
'Incompetent' murder case police accused
Officers named in Internet campaign for justice over graveyard stabbing of teen mother, writes Tony Thompson
Sunday May 14, 2000
Campaigners are using fly posters and the Internet in an attempt to secure justice for the family of a teenager brutally murdered nearly four years ago.
Katrina Taylor, 19, was found stabbed to death in a Brighton graveyard in July 1996. Despite two Crown Court trials, no one has been found guilty of her murder. Campaigners believe this is a result of the failure of the local force to investigate the crime properly and are demanding a full investigation by the Police Complaints Authority. They have distributed a list of Sussex officers who are accused of varying degrees of incompetence, from allegedly failing to take statements from key witnesses to not responding to tips about the whereabouts of the accused.
Taylor herself had taken part in a police murder reconstruction in 1986 posing as nine-year-old 'Babe in the Wood' Nicola Fellows, who had been strangled in a Brighton park. Ten years on she was struggling to bring up her baby daughter and fund her heroin habit. In May 1996 she acted as a lookout to a break-in at a flat owned by Neshia Williams, a petty criminal and girlfriend of a drug dealer.
When the intruders tried to steal the washing machine they accidentally flooded the house and set fire to the furniture. Williams began tracking down who was responsible, along with her brother, Simon, her boyfriend Trevor Smith and his flatmate Fergal Scollan. One of the intruders was beaten and stabbed in the leg with a screwdriver.
Taylor was spotted one afternoon outside a hotel by Simon Williams. In the run-up to the subsequent court case the manageress gave a statement saying Williams had dragged the screaming Taylor into his car, but in court she said Taylor had gone willingly - one of a number of conflicting reports. Taylor was taken to a flat where later that evening, Neshia Williams, Scollan and Smith all arrived to see her.
At 11.15pm, screaming was heard in the graveyard of a nearby church. Katrina's body was found the next morning. She had been stabbed five times in the chest, two of the wounds puncturing her heart. According to the pathologist's report, she had been held from behind and stabbed from the front by one or two people.
The four suspects were rounded up and gave a series of interviews to police which, they later admitted in court, were mostly lies. In July 1997, the four appeared at Lewes Crown Court charged with murder. Neshia and Simon Williams claimed Taylor had left the flat late that evening with Scollan and Smith. Scollan and Smith claimed she had left with the Williamses. After a three-week trial, the two Williamses were acquitted, but Scollan and Smith were found guilty of murder and jailed for life.
They appealed and were granted a retrial on the basis that the judge had misdirected the jury. But, because evidence relating to Neshia and Simon Williams could not be heard at the second trial, it collapsed and both men were acquitted.
Since then, Katrina Taylor's friends and family of have highlighted a number of alleged inconsistencies in the evidence presented in the first trial and claim that police ignored vital prosecution witnesses.
A Sussex police spokesperson told The Observer they were aware of the allegations but did not believe there was any new evidence. However, they appealed for any new witnesses to come forward.
Taylor's supporters plan to step up their campaign using fly posters to publicise a £10,000 reward for new information about the murder.
One campaigner said: 'We will not stop until someone has been found responsible for this murder. We want the police to be fully accountable for their actions in this case.'
The campaigners have drawn parallels with another Brighton murder in which Sussex police have been accused of failing to investigate properly. The family of Jay Abatan, a black accountant murdered outside a nightclub last year, joined forces with local MP Peter Bottomley last week to fight for justice.
Bottomley, MP for Eltham at the time of Stephen Lawrence's death, is keen to ensure the case is investigated thoroughly. 'It was at a similar stage in the proceedings after Lawrence's death that I became unhappy about the police investigation. I didn't ask for an inquiry early enough. I don't want to make the same mistake again.'